Table comparing how the SRA, BSB, CILEx Regulation and the CLC review continuing competence: the percentage reviewed, what was assessed, the findings and whether a record is required.

On 25 August 2026 two legal news sites reported about the same document. Legal Futures ran “Big spike in competence-related complaints to the SRA”, by Nick Hilborne. The Law Gazette ran “SRA satisfied with continuing competence - despite rise in complaints”, by John Hyde. Both headlines are accurate. Both are describing the Solicitors Regulation Authority’s (SRA) fourth annual assessment of continuing competence, published five days earlier.

Two readings that far apart, on the same day, about the same report, usually mean the report is doing two things at once; which this one is. It reports what the public complains about, and it reports what the regulator found when it looked at what solicitors actually do to stay competent. The second of those is the part I want to consider, because of one sentence that has had almost no attention at all.

What the review looked at

The SRA reviewed 123 training records from solicitors practising criminal and civil law, across 66 firms, covering 1 October 2024 to 30 September 2025. The SRA’s own population figures give 173,017 practising solicitors in July 2025, inside the review period, so the sample is about 0.07% of them. All 123 had completed some form of learning and development. Almost all had kept a record of it and it was up to date. Most of those who kept a record had completed between one and four learning activities; the focus being on maintaining technical legal practice.

Then this:

“Our review did not assess the quality or effectiveness of the learning and development carried out.”

That is not a criticism dressed up as a quotation. It is the regulator setting out the scope of its own exercise, plainly, in the body of its own report. I think it is the most useful sentence in the document, and it explains how two journalists reading carefully could come away with opposite headlines.

One more finding belongs beside it. Just under half of the records reviewed “did not explain how the learning need was identified and why it was important to address the issue”. On my reading what the SRA means by the word “issue” is the learning need itself. The record showed what the solicitor had done. It did not show what had prompted them to decide on that training or activity and why. In other words, the record did not show the self reflection behind the decision.

So, on the regulator’s own sample: everyone had done something. No-one was asked whether what they did worked. And in half the records, the step that determines whether the learning was the right learning is not evidenced.

This is not a small exercise, and I am not suggesting the SRA has been idle. Since 2023 it has reviewed more than 1,000 individual records across a range of practice areas. That is the point, rather than a qualification of it. A great deal of looking has been done, and none of it was looking at whether any of this makes anyone more competent.

What the BSB did

The Bar Standards Board (BSB) ran a comparable exercise and asked a different question. It requested 100 barristers’ 2023 CPD records after those barristers had declared compliance with their CPD obligations. The BSB’s published practising barrister figures give 17,782 at the 2023 snapshot, so the sample is about 0.6% of the Bar.

The headline reads well. 96% were assessed as compliant or compliant with feedback, against 87% in 2018, and 3% as non compliant, against 10% in 2018. On any ordinary reading, that is a regulator reporting improvement.

The finding underneath is the one that matters. Of the records assessed, 34 lacked adequate reflection and 31 lacked adequate learning objectives. One barrister was referred for possible enforcement action and 29 were made subject to further compliance checks in 2025. So roughly a third of the records that cleared the compliance test did not contain a usable account of why the learning was done or what it was for.

The lesson is not that barristers are worse at this than solicitors. Nothing here supports that, and the BSB says that it cannot draw statistically significant conclusions about compliance across the whole Bar from a sample of that size. The narrower point is about method. Those records had already passed the compliance test. The reflection gap was inside them, and it surfaced only because somebody read them to assess the adequacy of what they contained. Had the BSB only asked whether the record was there and whether the declaration had been made, then neither the 34 records lacking adequate reflection nor the 31 lacking adequate learning objectives would appear at all.

What CILEx Regulation does

I should say at the outset that I am far less familiar with CILEx regulation and the CILEx competence framework. I work daily with the SRA and BSB regimes and I do not hold myself out as knowing how the CILEx framework operates in practice. What follows is taken from CILEx Regulation’s own published material and nothing is inferred beyond it.

CILEx Regulation samples 2.5% of its regulated members every year and publishes an annual report of the exercise. In the 2024/2025 report, 302 members were selected, 293 submissions were assessed after nine exemptions were granted, 275 were assessed as compliant at 93.8% and 18 as non compliant at 6.1%. Full members, which includes CILEX Fellows, must complete nine CPD outcomes a year including at least one Professionalism outcome. CILEX Fellows who do not meet their CPD requirements cannot renew their practising certificate.

What the published report describes is whether a defined minimum was met, supported by evidence of the activities or outcomes completed. It does not describe an assessment of the quality of reflection, and it does not report themes or common shortcomings.

What the CLC is about to require

The Council for Licensed Conveyancers (CLC) belongs here too because it has already done what the SRA is currently consulting about. Again, this is not a framework I have worked with. The CLC does not publish a statement of competences in the way that the SRA, the BSB and CILEx Regulation do. Its Ongoing Competence Code is instead read alongside the CLC Code of Conduct, which comprises Ethical Principles with specific Outcomes sitting under each. One of those Outcomes requires that your skills and knowledge are up to date.

The CLC consulted on a proposed new Ongoing Competence Code in March and April 2025 and reported on the consultation on 28 May 2025. Its own page for the Code says the provisions take effect on 1 November 2026, and adds that the content there is illustrative and that the Code will be published on implementation. On that page, a CLC lawyer must: complete a minimum of eight ongoing competence activities a year, “of which at least four must be assessed”,; be able to demonstrate that they are professionally relevant and aligned with their practice areas, responsibilities or career goals; record and self certify each one in a prescribed format; submit the record and its evidence to the CLC by 31 October; and keep the evidence for four years.

So the CLC requires demonstration that an activity is professionally relevant, reflective of regulatory and industry change and aligned with the lawyer’s responsibilities. It calls for reflection, and at least half the activities must also be assessed. The CLC’s draft FAQs of July 2025 define an assessed activity as one in which “a CLC lawyer’s sound understanding of a topic is formally or informally assessed, verified, or evaluated”, and give as examples post training assessment producing a certificate or pass mark, and recorded feedback countersigned by a suitably qualified peer or colleague. A simple confirmation or certificate of attendance is listed separately, among the activities that are not assessed.

Four regulators, four different questions

Set the four side by side and what emerges is not a league table. It is four bodies asking genuinely different questions of the same underlying obligation.

The BSB asked whether the records were any good, and published the answer that roughly a third were not. CILEx Regulation asks whether a defined minimum has been met, checks a fixed proportion of its members every year, publishes the result and attaches the practising certificate to it. The CLC is about to require that half of a defined minimum is assessed by someone else. The SRA has reviewed more than 1,000 records since 2023, across several practice areas. Its current exercise covered 123, about 0.07% of practising solicitors, against about 0.6% of the Bar in the BSB’s single sample and 2.5% of CILEx Regulation’s members every year; and the SRA states that it did not assess quality at all.

The document they all answer to

On 28 July 2022 the Legal Services Board (LSB) issued a Statement of Policy on ongoing competence under section 49 of the Legal Services Act 2007 (LSA). It sets four outcomes that the LSA approved regulators must pursue:

  • set the standards of competence expected at authorisation and throughout a career;

  • “regularly determine the levels of competence within the profession(s) they regulate, and identify areas where competence may need to be improved”;

  • make appropriate interventions to maintain standards; and

  • take suitable remedial action where an individual falls short.

The LSB Statement of Policy states that regulators “must put in place measures to routinely collect relevant information about the competence of their authorised persons”, and the examples the LSB says they should consider include spot checks, audits and file reviews, feedback from consumers, supervisors, peers and the judiciary, and information from other agencies including the Legal Ombudsman and disciplinary tribunals. This is not advisory in effect: the LSB says it will have regard to regulators’ compliance with the statement in discharging its oversight functions, including in its assessment of regulators under the regulatory performance assessment framework.

What holds my attention, reading the four exercises above against that document, is how much room the second outcome leaves. “Regularly determine the levels of competence” does not say how. Counting how many people completed a record is one reading of it, although whether counting records determines anything about levels of competence is precisely the question in my mind. Reading what those records contain and forming a view about their quality is another. Both are possible readings of the same sentence, and the LSB says that regulators regulate different professions and authorised persons and “may adopt different approaches to pursue the stated outcomes”. The divergence is therefore permitted rather than accidental. What I am curious about is the consequence. Four regulators working to one set of outcomes are not collecting the same kind of information.

The SRA says in the report referred to above that it continues to participate in the Legal Services Regulators’ Ongoing Competence Forum, which it describes as allowing regulators to share insights, best practice, data and ideas on maintaining competence. I have not found published outputs from it. Whatever is shared there is not yet visible from outside, and the four exercises above do not point to a common view of what to measure.

The obvious objection is that these are four different professions with four different structures, which is why nothing above ranks anybody. The comparison is between four choices about what to measure, and on none of those choices does the published data yet tell us whether continuing competence has made a single lawyer more competent.

Yet in many areas, lawyers regulated by different bodies deliver the same or broadly similar services to clients. How are the regulators satisfying themselves that they meet their duty under section 28 of the LSA to act compatibly with the regulatory objective in section 1(1)(d), protecting and promoting the interests of consumers?

The rule the SRA is about to write

The SRA has consulted on introducing a rule requiring all solicitors to keep a record of their learning and development, showing that they have considered their role and work, identified any learning needs, and recorded how those needs were addressed. That consultation opened on 22 April 2026 and closed on 15 July 2026. The SRA says in the annual assessment that it will publish its post consultation position later this year, and that, subject to that analysis and to approval by the Legal Services Board, the rule would take effect from the start of the 2027/28 practising year.

11 years to a record

Here is the question I would actually like answered. The competences have been in place for over a decade. Why is a recording requirement necessary now, and why was it not introduced at the same time?

The sequence is worth setting out.

  • February 2015. The LSB agreed the SRA’s proposals to reform CPD.

  • 11 March 2015. The SRA Board approved publication of the Statement of Solicitor Competence, with the new approach open to solicitors who opted in from 1 April 2015.

  • September 2016. The BSB published the Professional Statement for Barristers, describing the knowledge, skills and attributes that all barristers will have on “day one” of practice.

  • 1 November 2016. The SRA’s new approach became compulsory for all solicitors, replacing a requirement to carry out 16 hours of learning and development each year.

  • 1 January 2017. The BSB’s CPD regime for Established Practitioners changed, with no minimum number of hours and instead a written CPD plan, a written record of activities and a written reflection each year.

  • January 2020. The LSB launched a call for evidence on ongoing competence.

  • February 2021. The LSB published its summary of evidence and its identification of emerging themes.

  • December 2021 to March 2022. The LSB consulted on the expectations.

  • 28 July 2022. The LSB issued the statement of policy on ongoing competence.

  • January 2024. The date by which the LSB expected regulators to provide assurance that they had met the four outcomes.

  • March and April 2025. The CLC consulted on a new Ongoing Competence Code.

  • 22 April to 15 July 2026. The SRA consulted on requiring solicitors to keep a record of their learning and development.

  • 1 November 2026. The CLC’s Ongoing Competence Code provisions take effect.

  • 2027/28 practising year. The earliest the SRA’s recording rule could apply, subject to the SRA’s post consultation analysis and to LSB approval.

11 years, and solicitors will not be required to keep a record of their learning and development until the 2027/28 practising year at the earliest.

What happened in between is the part that should trouble everybody, and it shows most clearly on the solicitor side, because that is where the recently published figures are. The declaration was made annually by every solicitor holding a practising certificate throughout, and nobody checked whether the learning behind it worked. The SRA’s own figures show competence related reports rising from 2,720 in 2024 to 4,038 in 2025, steady at 23% of all reports it receives, with 606 solicitors in 2025 saying they had not met the declaration requirements. I read the weekly disciplinary outcomes on both sides of the profession, and matters that on any ordinary reading involve a failure of competence continue to reach the tribunals. I am not going to attach a figure to that, because I have not seen one published that measures it. The absence of that figure is the point.

The speed of the machinery

There is a wider issue underneath the dates, and it is not really about competence at all. A modest change, a record in a prescribed form of learning a solicitor was already obliged to undertake, has taken 11 years and has not arrived yet. In those 11 years the work has changed, what clients expect of it has changed, and generative AI has entered legal practice to the point where both the SRA and the BSB have published on it inside the last four months.

A change cycle measured in more than a decade cannot keep step with that. The risk is not that the rules are wrong when they land. It is that they answer the profession as it was when the consultation opened.

So the question is really two:

  • Why, 11 years after the competences were set, is a record necessary now, and what is understood in 2026 that was not understood in 2015?

  • And if the honest answer is that it took this long to find out, then what do Government, the regulators and the professions propose to do about the speed at which regulatory change happens, so that the public can be assured of high quality regulated legal services without waiting until 2037?

Michaela Hardwick